Periodically the tweedy 'good port, good pipe, and no women' brand of Inklings Christianity makes me raise my eyebrows, but it still has it all over the fundamentalist version.

I don't remember the Toynbee article well, but wasn't her point that Lewis' 'worst sort of' God-figure is all-mighty and powerful? Never met a Christian version of God that wasn't, myself, unless Unitarians count as Christians.